August 09, 2001
House Subcommittee Passes the E-Fairness Buck
An Internet tax bill has finally made it out of committee in Washington, DC,
but it was not the bill that proponents of e-fairness were hoping for. However,
leading players in the fight to level the playing field between Internet and
bricks-and-mortar retailers remained confident that losing this early legislative
skirmish would not scuttle the chances of securing passage of e-fairness legislation
during this Congressional session.
On August 2, the House Judiciary Committee's Subcommittee on Commercial and
Administrative Law passed the "Internet Tax Nondiscrimination Act"
(H.R. 1552), sponsored by Representative Christopher Cox (R-CA) and sent the
bill on to the full Judiciary Committee, which is expected to consider it in
September, after the Congressional recess.
The proposed law extends the current ban on any new taxes on Internet purchases,
but it does not address the issue of the collection of sales tax on Web-based
transactions. During the subcommittee debate, Representative Melvin Watt (D-NC),
proposed an amendment to H.R. 1552 that would have both encouraged states to
simplify their sales tax regulations and would have promised that Congress would
consider the collection of sales tax on e-commerce sales once 25 states had
agreed on sales tax regulation changes.
However, Watt's amendment was ruled non-germane by the Subcommittee chair,
Representative Bob Barr (R-GA).
For e-fairness supporters, however, the fight is far from over. Following
the Subcommittee vote, Watt said he would reintroduce his amendment when the
full Judiciary Committee considers the bill. "This is a minor-league trial
period. We get to the major leagues next," he said, as reported by Reuters.
Lisa Cowell, executive director of the E-Fairness Coalition, noted to the Washington
Post that she was not disappointed with the Subcommittee vote. "This was
barely a skirmish in the fight," she said. ABA and a number of the regional
booksellers associations, as well as many other retailers and businesses nationwide,
are members of the e-Fairness Coalition.
-Dan Cullen
Topics: Internet Commerce, Sales Tax Initiative, News - Bookselling,
|